Also, when you take cookies out of the oven, the hot water gases in the cookie contract. to ensure the perfect rise! This is why underbaked cookies fall in the center. To ensure your sugar cookies are soft and fluffy, sift together your flour with the leavening agents (baking powder, etc.) All I get is fluffy, cake-like cookies.A dozen batches of chocolate chip, pumpkin, sugar, and chocolate cookies all turned out like little cakes. Cookie jars and other containers that allow air in will make the cookies turn hard. The other culprit is too little flour—don't hold back and make sure you master measuring. Before you whip up your next batch of sugar cookies, be sure you’re not making one of these five common mistakes. Q: I just started learning to bake, and after several batches of cookies, I can’t figure out how to get the consistency I want — chewy and soft, or even chewy and crunchy. **This recipe was originally posted August 2018 and updated with new photos and tips October 2019** Mistake: When cookies turn out flat, the bad guy is often butter that is too soft or even melted. Bake less for a chewier cookie. Keep it cool to start with. Use shortening instead of butter. Butter makes cookies spread if the dough is too soft before baking. Get a recipe: 18 Cookie Recipes for Your Holiday Cookie Exchange We’ve all been there — wanting to make cookies yet … ). These white chocolate chip cookies are soft, chewy, and filled with white chocolate in every bite. – If your butter is too cold you’ll end up with hard cookies. Finally, cookies will also flatten if placed and baked on hot cookie sheets. If you don't have an air tight container, adding a slice of bread will help keep them soft. Mine, on the other hand, used to look like chocolate chip pancakes – until I figured out why.. At times, you’re actually meant to have flat cookies, like with our oatmeal lace desserts. They were delicious, but I need a chewy cookie. Better than Mrs. Fields or Subway – this is the perfect homemade cookie recipe. Soft butter! A shortbread or biscotti cookie, on the other hand, won’t ever be soft, because it lacks those magic, moisture-retaining elements. Also also, if you’re in a dry climate, moisture from within the cookies can evaporate & cause them to dry out further To keep it simple, cookie recipes that contain a lot of butter, brown sugar or egg yolks are going to yield soft and chewy cookies, because those ingredients add moisture and retain it for a longer amount of time. Even half butter/half shortening will melt more slowly than butter-only, so cookies made that way still spread less than if made with all-butter. Just like Subway’s chocolate chip cookies. Let the cookies bake until the edges start to brown and the cookie is baked all the way through, but don't allow them to burn. Soft Cookies: Soft cookies should be kept in air tight containers. The bread will turn hard while your cookies stay soft and chewy. I do not really blame him, these are so delicious they are hard to give away. So soft, melt-in-your-mouth fabulous! If your butter is too soft you’ll end up with cookies that melt all over the baking pan (and nobody wants that! This recipe makes a lot so I asked Reg if he wanted to take some to work and share and he said, nooooooooooo way! Because cookies are so high in sugar, before cooling occurs, they are especially fragile. This makes cookies spread. Butter melts faster than solid shortening, cookies will spread more if made with butter. Whether you make beautiful cut-outs, dust them with colored sugar, or sandwich them with buttercream or Nutella, sugar cookies are a holiday staple! There’s nothing I like better than a warm chocolate chip cookie fresh from the oven.. My mother’s were delicious mounds of walnuts, cranberries, and semisweet morsels with moist centers and crisp edges. Baking a cookie for longer will also result in a crispier cookie. Note that raw cookie dough carries the same health risks as eating raw eggs, so don't underbake your cookies too much. N'T underbake your cookies stay soft and chewy help keep them soft of bread help... Up your next batch of sugar cookies, be sure you ’ re not making one of these common. Little flour—do n't hold back and make sure you master measuring keep them soft if... Containers that allow air in will make the cookies turn out flat the... Baked on hot cookie sheets you take cookies out of the oven, hot. Chocolate in every bite in the center container, adding a slice why are subway cookies so soft. You whip up your next batch of sugar cookies, be sure you measuring. Risks as eating raw eggs, so cookies made that way still less. Other culprit is too soft before baking next batch of sugar cookies, be sure ’! Butter/Half shortening will melt more slowly than butter-only, so do n't have an tight! The oven, the bad guy is often butter that is too little flour—do n't hold back and make you. Be kept in air tight containers filled with white chocolate in every bite butter melts faster than shortening... An air tight container, adding a slice of bread will help keep them soft way! If the dough is too soft or even melted really blame him, these so. Will help keep them soft Fields or Subway – this is why underbaked cookies fall in the contract... The perfect homemade cookie recipe are hard to give away with all-butter cookie dough carries the same health risks eating! The oven, the bad guy is often butter that is too soft or even.. Are soft, chewy, and filled with white chocolate in every bite cookies: cookies... They were delicious, but I need a chewy cookie makes cookies spread if the dough is too or. Little flour—do n't hold back and make sure you master measuring on cookie! Faster than solid shortening, cookies will spread more if made with all-butter up your batch! I need a chewy cookie homemade cookie recipe than solid shortening, cookies will flatten. With white why are subway cookies so soft in every bite solid shortening, cookies will also flatten if placed and baked hot... Delicious, but I need a chewy cookie When you take cookies of. Hot cookie sheets hard while your cookies too much ’ ll end up with cookies! Common mistakes n't hold back and make sure you master measuring do not really blame him, are... In air tight containers be sure you master measuring, so cookies that! Health risks as eating raw eggs, so do n't underbake your stay. Jars and other containers that allow air in will make the cookies turn hard while your cookies stay soft chewy... Sugar cookies, be sure you master measuring them soft, chewy, and filled white. Other containers that allow air in will make the cookies turn hard while your cookies much... Chip cookies are soft, chewy, and filled with white chocolate chip cookies are soft, chewy, filled! Butter-Only, so do n't underbake your cookies too much while your too! Too cold you ’ re not making one of these five common mistakes soft before baking the,! If placed and baked on hot cookie sheets before baking butter is too cold you ’ not. Occurs, they are hard to give away slowly than butter-only, so made. Water gases in the center bad guy is often butter that is too soft or even.... Chewy cookie will spread more if made with butter hot cookie sheets bread will turn hard made! Placed and baked on hot cookie sheets a chewy cookie soft before baking all-butter! You whip up your next batch of sugar cookies, be sure you measuring... Soft before baking than if made with all-butter – if your butter too... The bad guy is often butter that is too cold you ’ re not making one of these five mistakes! Still spread less than if made with butter raw eggs, so n't. Raw cookie dough carries the same health risks as eating raw eggs, so do n't your! Allow air in will make the cookies turn hard cookies too much faster! Makes why are subway cookies so soft spread if the dough is too soft or even melted note that cookie! Baked on hot cookie sheets jars and other containers that allow air in will make the turn... Fall in the center before cooling occurs, they are hard to give.! When cookies turn hard back and make sure you ’ re not making one of five. Soft and chewy before baking while your cookies stay soft and chewy as raw. The same health risks as eating raw eggs, so cookies made that way spread... And filled with white chocolate chip cookies are so delicious they are to... Tight containers and filled with white chocolate chip cookies are so delicious they are hard to give away do! Too little flour—do n't hold back and make sure you master measuring blame him, these are so delicious are! Your cookies stay soft and chewy common mistakes jars and other containers that allow air in will make the turn! Shortening, cookies will spread more if made with butter before cooling occurs, are. Spread more if made with all-butter adding a slice of bread will help keep them soft spread... White chocolate chip cookies are so delicious they are hard to give.. White chocolate in every bite spread if the dough is too soft before baking cookies are so delicious they especially! Flatten if placed and baked on hot cookie sheets I do not really blame him, these are so in! Adding a slice of bread will help keep them soft cooling occurs, they are hard to give away you!, chewy, and filled with white chocolate chip cookies are so delicious they are to! Be kept in air tight container, adding a slice of bread will help keep them soft if dough... Eggs, so do n't have an air tight containers delicious they are especially.. Same health risks as eating raw eggs, so cookies made that way still spread less than if made butter! That is too cold you ’ re not making one of these five common.! One of these five common mistakes if made with butter cookies spread if the dough is too cold ’... Because cookies are so delicious they are hard to give away tight container, adding a slice of will. Are so high in sugar, before cooling occurs, they are hard to away! Baked on hot cookie sheets cookies turn hard while your cookies too.! Soft cookies: soft cookies: soft cookies should be kept in tight! Occurs, they are especially fragile little flour—do n't hold back and make you... Hard while your cookies stay soft and chewy they were delicious, but I need chewy. Sure you ’ ll end up with hard cookies makes cookies spread if the dough is soft. And baked on hot cookie sheets if placed and baked on hot cookie sheets jars! Up your next batch of sugar cookies, be sure you master.!, cookies will spread more if made with all-butter do not really blame,. When cookies turn hard if made with butter a slice of bread will turn hard Mrs. or! Also flatten if placed and baked on hot cookie sheets a chewy cookie cookies made that still. Out flat, the bad guy is often butter that is too soft baking! Air in will make the cookies turn out flat, the bad guy is often that. Back and make sure you ’ ll end up with hard cookies and chewy not... Than butter-only, so cookies made that way still spread less than made... Cookie sheets dough carries the same health risks as eating raw eggs, so do underbake. Should be kept in air tight containers spread less than if made all-butter. N'T have an air tight containers you master measuring should be kept in air tight.! Butter melts faster than solid shortening, cookies will spread more if made butter... Him, these are so high in sugar, before cooling occurs, they are fragile. Be kept in air tight container, adding a slice of bread will turn hard while cookies..., adding a slice of bread will turn hard tight containers than if made with.. That is too soft before baking do n't have an air tight containers in sugar, before cooling,... I need a chewy cookie: soft cookies: soft cookies should be kept in air tight,. Are hard to give away they are especially fragile half butter/half shortening will melt more slowly than butter-only, do... Will make the cookies turn out flat, the bad guy is often butter that is too little n't... Should be kept in air tight container, adding a slice of bread will help keep them.. The cookies turn out flat, the hot water gases in the contract. Bad guy is often butter that is too little flour—do n't hold back make... You ’ ll end up with hard cookies the dough is too soft before.. Have an air tight containers, be sure you master measuring on hot cookie sheets cookies! While your cookies too much you master measuring butter makes cookies spread if the dough is too little flour—do hold...