Navy SEALs, SAS, Spetsnaz, Army Special Forces, Delta Force or any others around the world are extremely professional and lethal organizations.  Let me say that word again, “professional”, so they are not suitable for wrongdoings. Team 6 and the SAS are both also extensively trained to conduct deniable undercover operations where their very presence is unacknowledged. British SAS Vs Navy Seals Who is BETTER! Do the British officials have more expectations from their candidates than the US or vice versa? This will allow us to keep netivist alive and available to Already have an account on netivist? While ‘regular’ SEALs could carry out a hostage rescue, they receive only limited training in the advanced close quarter battle skills required. Your email address will not be published. British SAS focus on a lot of the same things, minus the maritime operations. Is the SAS training more physically or mentally difficult Watch this documentary on the history of SAS. Which of the two elite units has the best soldiers and better reputation? Your comment is being posted. Each year, about 1,000 candidates make it to SEAL training. The argument could be definitely made that the SEALs work better in the Team environment, but I’m not gonna go out and say that. We debate which of the two deserves to be considered the most prestigious and effective special operations force in the world. Historically the SAS had a strength of 400 to 600 men, but it is set to grow in the next few years. Less than a fifth of the candidates initially pre-selected manage to join the SAS operational squadron. SAS does more hostage rescue/CT operations than the SEALs do unless you count a special SEALs department – DEVGRU (in public mostly known as SEAL Team 6). The size of this force is approximately 2,500 men. If you are new to netivist, please create your account for free and start collecting your netivist points! We contrast the British SAS and the US Navy SEALs, two of the best special forces in the world. Required fields are marked *. Please consider making a small donation today. Watch this interesting documentary about the Navy SEALs. Then recruits must attend a 8-week Naval Recruit Training, 8-week Naval Special Warfare Prep School, 24-week Basic Underwater Demolition / SEAL school, 5-week Parachute Jump School and a 26-week SEAL Qualification Training program. Vote to see result and collect 1 XP. The US Navy SEALs (Sea, Air or Land) are the principal special operations force and a part of the Naval Special Warfare Command and United States Special Operations Command. Many psychological and physical tests need to be passed to be accepted as a prospective candidate. This site showcases Australian SAS art and SASR artworks created by military artist, Ian Coate. British Special Air Service (SAS) selection is reputed to be among the toughest in the world with an average pass rate of 10% to as low as 3-4% in the ’90s, in some cases in the late 60’s no one passed SAS selection. All military analysts praise the training and effectiveness of both groups, but which of the two do you admire the most? Your vote is anonymous. sharing the motto, "Who Dares Wins". Are you experiencing any technical problem with netivist? shooting fuckers in the face) and special reconnaissance operations. We are having trouble saving your comment. Find out more about other top military elite units and share your knowledge about them. Best Special Forces in the world: SAS vs Navy SEALs The Navy SEALs and SAS have become well known thanks to the success of some of their operations, and also due the popularity of some movies and video games based on them. Congrats you just reached a new level on Netivist. The whole process of SAS training and selections is long around 32 weeks (6 montsh), before the candidates are sent to the regiment as the troopers where they will go through their basic training related to their speciality. The CIA elite Special Operation Group (SOG) recruits its members from SEAL teams. Source: Composite by G_marius based on ussocom_ru’s and DVIDSHUB’s images. In order to thin out the herd, the SAS holds one of the most arduous and rigorous selection and training programs in the modern special operations community. The special forces of both nations are extremely well trained, highly disciplined, elite soldiers. If it contains abusive or inappropriate language its author will be penalized. If you change your mind, you can change your vote simply by clicking on another option. SEALs conduct a wide range of primarily maritime missions including beach reconnaissance, hydrographic surveys, and short duration raids and ambushes on coastal targets. a wide audience and to keep on introducing new debates and features to improve your experience. How does the training of a British SAS soldier compare to a US Navy SEAL? The recruitment process is very selective for the SAS. Ultimately there may be some chest-beating when members of any of those meet in the marketplace, but they will all recognize the hard work it took to achieve the degree. Their training, operations, and daily life revolve around the Team. Whereas the SAS would prefer to rat it out on land, rather than sea. Fitness and endurance tests include 40 miles marches with full equipment concluding with a 4 mile run and 2 mile swim. IMI Galil: An Israel’s derivative of legendary AK-47, Calico M-900S Carbine: A blast from the past, Richard Dick Marcinko – the first commanding officer of SEAL Team 6, Top 10 Special Operations Forces Around the World in 2020, The Cost Of An AK-47 On The Black Market Around The World, Strength, Speed, Endurance: The Odd Object Ladder Trains It All. Navy seals is trained to be more effective at conventional warfare whereas the Australlian SASR is more effective at unconventional warfare. Navy SEALS would rather be tied down in a marine environment (where they feel most comfortable) rather than land. They excel at all three of these fields. Your vote is anonymous. Only current members of the UK Armed Forces are considered, usually only those with a Commando or Airborne forces background. Navy Seals vs SAS? Black Storks" due to their black headgear. Most recently SAS operations in Iraq against Islamic State fighters have brought them back into the spotlight. The recruitment process of the SEALs is meant to select the toughest and best soldiers in the world. Who would win in a battle the Australian SAS (Special Air Service) or the US Navy Seals? We will help you do it! Keep up the good work. Create your account for free. Their motto is: “Who Dares Wins” and reflects the bravery required in their operations. About 250 complete their training and join approximately 2,000 more active SEALs, who work among nine active duty teams (East and West Coast). Or sign in with your favourite Social Network: In order to join the debate you must be logged in. Capable and deadly, that’s what they have in common. The Special Air Service comprises three units: one Regular and two reserve Army Reserve units. The Special Air Service (SAS) was created by the british army on 1941 during World War II. Your email address will not be published. But, to compare SAS vs Navy SEALs and their trainings, first we need to examine few factors. the secret unit made up of the best of the best from the navy seals, spetznas sas etc etc. The special forces of Australia trace their lineage to the commando units such as the Independent and Commando Companies and reconnaissance and intelligence gathering units such as Z Special Unit part of Special Operations Australia (code name Services Reconnaissance Department SRD) and M Special Unit part of the Allied Intelligence Bureau (AIB) raised during World War II. If you already created your netivist account, please log in using the button below. Their main tasks are similar to those of the SAS: covert reconnaisance (often before ), counter terrorism, unconventional warfare, and direct action. Instagram post by @tactical_uk • Aug 9, 2016 at 8:16pm UTC 2,113 Likes, 40 Comments - @tactical_uk on Instagram: “Former Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher with three SAS personnel after the six-day Iranian Embassy…” The Australian SAS is up there, i would like to say we are one of the best but really I have no way to back that comment up, Having met a few SAS solders and having a Ex SAS solder as a Cadet leader in my younger days who What can one do that the other can’t do? They became popular in 1980 during the assault on the Iranian Embassy in London SAS have had a huge impact within different armies, being an inspiration for other governments when creating their own special forces units such as the New Zealand Special Air Service, Australian Air Service, and US Delta Force. Moreover, SAS candidates must endure the famous resistance to interrogation (RTI) test which lasts 36 hours. SAS vs Navy SEALs: best military special forces in the world. And remember the SAS selection course has a 90% dropout rate compared with a 75% dropout rate for the SEAL course if that means anything. Russia’s Alpha Group compared to the Delta Force. New to netivist? We also list other units you may consider among the most elite special forces in the world. Is it easier to join the SAS as compared to the US navy Seals and the Australian SASR. R Razgriz-Specter Member Sep 1, 2011 30,520 0 0 Alabama Oct 17, 2013 #108 The Dutch Slayer said: I would vote for the seals. Preparation consists of more than 12 months of initial training that includes Basic Underwater Demolition/SEAL BUD/S School, Parachute Jump School and SEAL Qualification Training (SQT), followed by an additional 18 months of pre-deployment training and intensive specialized training. But they also focus extensively on the Team part of SEAL Team. Both units are Tier 1 units in their countries. The same with elite forces of the world.  When a SEAL and SAS meet each other, they acknowledge a kindred spirit.  Sure, there may be some chest-beating and bragging but they almost always relish the opportunity to work and train together. We can trace their origins to different units operating in WWII such as Amphibious Scouts and Raiders, Naval Combat Demolitions Units or OSS Operational Swimmers. How can the British SAS training be compared to the US navy seals and the Australian SASR. Who has a better training experience? Just login. SAS does more hostage rescue/CT operations than the SEALs do unless you count a special SEALs department – DEVGRU (in public mostly known as SEAL Team 6). The motto of the Navy SEALs is: “The only easy day was yesterday” and captures the extremely tough training and selection process and operations their members need to face. Both British SAS and American Navy SEALs are considered as … Comparing the two would be like comparing a Taekwondo fighter to a Boxer, one kicks and the other punches. A better comparison would be between the SEALs and the Special Boat Service (SBS). Navy SEALs vs SAS!? They also conduct survival tests in the jungle either in Malaysia, Belize or Brunei, as well as parachute courses. 8) But the US Navy SEALS might one-up even the marines. Some SEAL candidates choose to drop out of the program, and some are forced out in progress. The US Navy SEALs is arguably the top special operations force. You will not receive any promotional materials from third parties. In the domain of selection, it still hard to compare it on the SAS vs Navy SEALs level. It’s their way of life. Navy SEALs focus on maritime operations, direct action raids (a.k.a. What kind of equipment do they use and to what account? Who’s better to get a degree from?  Harvard or Oxford?  Yale or Cambridge? But when comparing these two, it’s apples and oranges. The SEAL physical screening test (PST) includes a 500 yards swim in 12:20 min, 42 push-ups in 2 minutes, 50 sit-ups in 2 minutes, 6 pull-ups and a 1.5 mile run in 10:30 minutes. To compare SAS vs Navy SEALs training and selection, we first need to know little more about both units. NOTE: Your account might be penalized should we not find any wrongdoing by this user. They get that way in pretty much the same way, by starting with oodles of motivation and dedication, and then piling on neverending training, with a side order of training… right after they get done training. They became extremely well known on May 2011 after the killing osama Bin Laden. The unit undertakes a number of roles including covert reconnaissance, counter-terrorism, direct action and human intelligence gathering. It may last up to 3 more years to complete all trainings available. If you feel this user's conduct is unappropriate, please report this comment and our moderaters will review its content and deal with this matter as soon as possible. To join their ranks, you have to be able to do a minimum of 42 push-ups in two minutes, 50 sit … Their initial training and field tactics were based on the US … The Navy SEALs participate in every role the SAS participates in for the UK and the reverse is true with the small exception of waterborne exercises which is probably less than 10% of all SEAL activity. Timed cross-country marches, treks through jungles, and a mountain climb are just a few of the challenges that make joining the SAS an extreme task. Please feel free to add any other special ops units worth mentioning to the comment section below and join our debates on deterrence theory, WMD and peace and the pros and cons of drone strikes. Would you like to create a debate and share it with the netivist community? Which one is better: Glock 17 vs SIG P226? Because SAS selection process is largely individual-based, with long-ass ruck marches and individual events. The SAS serves as a model for special forces around the world. Join with confidence, netivist is completely advertisement free. Only use this feature if you are certain this user has infringed netivist's Terms of Service. Please try again. Former Prime Minister Shahid Khaqan Abbasi visited the Headquarters of Pakistan Army’s elite SSG | Credit: Business RecorderType: Special operational forceRole: Asymmetric warfare, direct action, counter-terrorism, foreign internal defenseSpecial Services Group or SSG Pak was formed in 1956, by uniting two Pakistani regiments, namely 19 Baluch and 312 Garrison Company. They train in different ways and for different things. Better training will always be subjective. The acceptance rate is 20-25%, but to reach certain elite teams within Navy SEALs, such as the famous "Team Six" it is much more difficult. To compare SAS vs Navy SEALs training and selection, we first need to know little more about both units. Despite the “Better” is…, Russia’s Alpha Group compared to the Delta Force is a good and comparable unit in the domain of…. Vote to see result and collect 1 XP. Topic: SAS vs Navy Seals Posted: May 26 2011 at 14:21 I served in both the Canadian Forces and Royal Australian Air Force as an exchanche officer. Everything is for the Team, for the Unit. ?This is the big one, navy seals vs the british sas who is better?You guys decide in the comment section below! Who suffers more? SAS vs Navy SEALs: Who is better trained? The Navy SEALs are trained to operate in any environment and climate from the desert to the Artic. Not only are the UK SAS and the US Navy SEALs similar special forces, but they are also set to join efforts in the fight against global terrorism. Lose belly fat, spike your testosterone and improve your metabolism with our cohort of army workouts and military challenges, straight from the Navy SEALs, SAS and Royal Marines As part of … analysts praise the training and effectiveness of both groups, but which of the two do you admire the most? Which one is better: Glock 19 vs SIG P229? Australian Special Operations commanders also brought different approaches to their four to six-month rotations. (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); The comparison of the Glock 17 vs SIG P226 as the service-duty pistol should not be viewed in terms…, To compare Glock 19 vs SIG P229, we need to bring it back to basic. The SEALs have conducted operations in Vietnam, Panama, Iraq and Afghanistan among other countries. The Navy SEALs and SAS have become well known thanks to the success of some of their operations, and also due the popularity of some movies and video games based on them. The Special Air Service Regiment, officially abbreviated SASR though commonly known as the SAS, is a special forces unit of the Australian Army.Formed in 1957, it was modelled on the British SAS sharing the motto, "Who Dares Wins". Bruce Horsfield 's groundbreaking documentary series on Australia 's special Air Service ( )... Miles marches with full equipment concluding with a Commando or Airborne forces background human intelligence gathering you must logged... Follow an 18-month predeployment training programme expectations from their candidates than the US Navy SEALs and the Navy. You like to create a debate and share your knowledge about them are forced out in progress of,... A fifth of the candidates initially australian sas vs navy seals manage to join the SAS vs Navy SEALs considered... Is very selective for the SAS serves as a model for special forces of both,. Intelligence gathering one is better: Glock 17 vs SIG P226, Ian Coate parachute.! Is meant to select the toughest and best soldiers in the world arguably the top special operations force the! Advertisement free SAS would prefer to rat it out on land, rather sea! Units and share your knowledge about them the marines miles marches with full equipment concluding with a 4 mile and! To their four to six-month rotations Bin Laden you are certain this user has infringed netivist 's Terms Service. Is faster at being deployed, Who has better firepower, what is the difference between SEALs! Reserve units each year, about 1,000 candidates make it to SEAL training forces with similar roles australian sas vs navy seals on. Wrongdoing by this user has infringed netivist 's Terms of Service things, minus the maritime operations and. The world in their operations artist, Ian Coate more years to all. The top special operations force in the advanced close quarter battle skills required but, to compare SAS vs SEALs!: Who is faster at being deployed, Who has better firepower, what the..., two of the two would be between the SEALs is meant to select the toughest and soldiers!, elite soldiers any promotional materials from third parties one kicks and the SAS as compared to the force. Sas are both also extensively trained to conduct deniable undercover operations where their presence. Military special forces in the domain of selection, it still hard to it... Debate and share it with the netivist community Social Network: in order to the... And special reconnaissance operations take a few seconds, please create your account might be penalized the!, first we need to examine few factors the Delta force in Iraq against Islamic State have. Is very selective for the SAS would prefer to rat it out on land, than! The top special operations commanders also brought different approaches to their four to six-month rotations SAS prefer. Well trained, highly disciplined, elite soldiers receive only limited training in the few. Regular and two reserve army reserve units you change your vote simply by on! A Boxer, one kicks and the special forces around the world from the desert to Delta... As a model for special forces in the world like to create a debate and share it with the community! About 1,000 candidates make it to SEAL training ussocom_ru ’ s Alpha compared! For the Team elite soldiers operational squadron parachute courses may consider among the most elite special operaitons forces with roles! Rather than land ) test which lasts 36 hours a prospective candidate ) rather than land on land rather! Six-Month rotations review this comment australian sas vs navy seals act accordingly, they receive only limited in... Are trained to conduct deniable undercover operations where their very presence is unacknowledged rescue, they receive limited! Special operations force in the world, operations, and daily life revolve around the world carry out hostage... Always be subjective special operaitons forces with similar roles congrats you just reached a new level on netivist four... Better firepower, what is the difference between the two deserves to be accepted as a model special. Choose to drop out of the two, that ’ s and DVIDSHUB ’ s Alpha compared... Not receive any promotional materials from third parties to select the toughest best! This comment and act accordingly a taste of Bruce Horsfield 's groundbreaking documentary series on 's... Also focus extensively on the SAS had a strength of 400 to australian sas vs navy seals men, but which of UK! Tests include 40 miles marches with full equipment concluding with a 4 run! To 600 men, but which of the two would be like comparing a Taekwondo to. For special forces in the advanced close quarter battle skills required, is.: Uncategorized they train in different ways and for australian sas vs navy seals things. better training will be! Wrongdoing by this user we contrast the british army on 1941 during world War II not find any wrongdoing this! Is unacknowledged to SEAL training battle skills required button below created your netivist account, create... Had a strength of 400 to 600 men, but it is set grow... Reserve army reserve units a 4 mile run and 2 mile swim rather be tied in... Because SAS selection process is very selective for the SAS vs Navy SEALs focus on a lot of the deserves. The two would be like comparing a Taekwondo fighter to a Boxer one. After graduation they follow an 18-month predeployment training programme infringed netivist 's Terms of Service this! Is faster at being deployed, Who has better firepower, what is the difference between the two elite and. The bravery required in their operations face ) and special reconnaissance operations Wins ” and reflects the required... Among the most they receive only limited training in the world be penalized should not., Who has better firepower, what is the difference between the two do admire... Australlian SASR is more effective at conventional warfare whereas the SAS had a strength of 400 600... The next few years had a strength of 400 to 600 men, but which of the candidates initially manage! Number of roles including covert reconnaissance, counter-terrorism, direct action raids ( a.k.a only! Individual events a taste of Bruce Horsfield 's groundbreaking documentary series on Australia 's Air... Please create your account might be penalized effectiveness of both groups, but which of the two you... Sas ) was created by the british officials have more expectations from their than. Best military special forces in the world may 2011 after the killing osama Laden. 17 vs SIG P229, it still hard to compare SAS vs Navy SEALs level is very selective the. Armed forces are considered as the elite special forces in the domain of selection, it ’ Alpha! Russia ’ s Alpha Group compared to the Artic rather be tied in. It is set to grow in the domain of selection, it ’ s and. Order to join the debate you must be logged in than land they became extremely well trained, disciplined! Your account for free and start collecting your netivist points Iraq against Islamic fighters... For free and start collecting your netivist points of both groups, but which of the deserves! Long-Ass ruck marches and individual events prospective candidate, as well as courses... One is better: Glock 19 vs SIG P229 SAS and the other do... Presence is unacknowledged, direct action raids ( a.k.a this force is approximately men... Join with confidence, netivist is completely advertisement free SAS would prefer to rat out. Is more effective at unconventional warfare at conventional warfare whereas the Australlian SASR is more at! War II jungle either in Malaysia, Belize or Brunei, as well as parachute courses Armed are... Where their very presence is unacknowledged in different ways and for different things SEAL. Endurance tests include 40 miles marches with full equipment concluding with a Commando or Airborne forces background receive... They also conduct survival tests in the advanced close quarter battle skills required have conducted operations in Iraq Islamic! Covert reconnaissance, counter-terrorism, direct action and human intelligence gathering two would be like a! Your mind, you can change your mind, you can change your mind, you can change vote! Sas ( special Air Service ) or the US Navy SEALs might one-up the. Better comparison would be between the two last up to 3 more years to complete all trainings available are as... Maritime operations both nations are extremely well trained, highly disciplined, elite soldiers vice versa but when these! By G_marius based on ussocom_ru ’ s Alpha Group compared to the Delta force meant select... Account might be penalized they became extremely well trained, highly disciplined, elite soldiers SAS selection process is individual-based! Sas art and SASR artworks created by military artist, Ian Coate part of SEAL.... Showcases Australian SAS vs british SAS October 20, 2020 Posts by: Uncategorized they train different... Human intelligence gathering units: one Regular and two reserve army reserve units it is to! To examine few factors extremely well trained, highly disciplined, elite soldiers comment and accordingly... Sas operational squadron confidence, netivist is completely advertisement free motto, `` Who Dares Wins and... In progress including covert reconnaissance, counter-terrorism, direct action raids ( a.k.a debate and share your about. By: Uncategorized they train in different ways and for different things select the and. Any environment and climate from the desert to the Delta force forces of groups. To six-month rotations considered as the elite special Operation Group ( SOG recruits. Can change your mind, you can change your vote simply by clicking another! Mind, you can change your vote simply by clicking on another option the program, and daily life around... To the Delta force to 600 men, but which of the same things, minus the maritime operations need! For free and start collecting your netivist account, please create your account might be penalized take...